عنوان مقاله [English]
The book "Readings" is one of the earliest books in quoting distorted narrations and is one of the most important sources cited by Muhaddith Nouri in proving the distortion of the Holy Quran. Considering that most of the volume of the book "Readings" is dedicated to distorted narrations, examining the correctness or incorrectness of these hadiths requires special necessity. By adopting a descriptive-analytical method, this research intends to study and critique the document and content of the narrations of the mentioned book under the verses of Surah Yasin. The findings show that out of the fourteen planetary narrations following the verses of Surah Yasin, seven are distorted. The narrations of reciting the words "Sanktab" instead of "and Naktub" under the twelfth verse, and reciting "Lamstaqr" instead of the word "Lamstaqr" under verse 38 of Surah Yasin, are weak in terms of document and in terms of content of this recitation. The reason for the inadequacy in the expression of meaning - can not be considered the original reading. In four narrations with the same document, interpretive additions have been quoted which are weak due to the presence of "Ibn Hamza Bataini" in the chain of the document; From the point of view of semantics, considering the inconsistency with the context and appropriateness of the verses, these interpretive additions cannot be considered as part of the Quranic text.
The conversion of the phrase "Mamma La Ya'lamun" to "Mamma Ya'qlun" in verse 36 of Surah Yasin destroys the relevance of the verse